Investor sentiment has moved from cautious to genuinely fearful. Concerns over Fed policy, energy prices, the durability of AI-related capital spending, and geopolitical tension have produced a real wall of worry, and it shows up clearly across every gauge we track. The AAII Investor Sentiment Survey showed bullish sentiment at just 28.8% in the week ended September 16 versus 53.3% bearish — a -24.5 bull-bear spread, the lowest bullish reading since May 2025 and roughly three standard deviations below the survey’s long-run average of +6.5. The CNN Fear & Greed Index sits near 30 (“Fear”), and the NAAIM Exposure Index has fallen sharply as well.
