There’s an old saying about family wealth: “shirtsleeves to shirtsleeves in three generations.” It shows up in different cultures under different names, and the pattern behind it is remarkably consistent. Roughly 40% of family businesses transition successfully to a second generation. About 13% make it to a third. Only around 3% endure beyond that.
The instinct is to assume this happens because of bad tax planning, poor investment choices, or a business that simply ran its course. Sometimes that’s true. But in our experience and in the research behind these numbers, the more common cause is quieter: families that never talked about the money until it was too late to plan together.
Tax and legal strategy can only work with the information and consensus a family gives it. A perfectly drafted trust doesn’t help if the next generation doesn’t understand why it exists, resents how it was structured, or was never consulted about decisions that affect them. Wealth transfer plans fail more often from a breakdown in communication and trust than from a flaw in the documents.
This is especially true around a major liquidity event, like the sale of a family business. The transaction itself gets enormous attention: the valuation, the buyer, the terms. The conversation about what the resulting wealth means for the family, how decisions will be made, and what role each generation will play, often gets far less.
We’ve sat in enough of these conversations to notice a pattern: families who wait for a single big meeting to cover everything tend to leave with more questions than answers, while families who build a habit of smaller, regular conversations, even brief ones, tend to arrive at major decisions with far less friction. The goal isn’t one perfect conversation. It’s making the topic normal enough that nobody is hearing about the family’s financial plans for the first time at a moment of stress.
A structured, advisor-led family conversation started well before a transaction and revisited regularly afterward is one of the highest-value planning tools available. It is also one of the most consistently skipped. It doesn’t replace a good estate plan. It’s what makes a good estate plan work as intended, across generations instead of just one.
If your family hasn’t had this conversation yet, don’t worry, it’s common. But it is worth changing. The families who beat the odds usually aren’t the ones with the cleverest tax strategy. They’re the ones who talked to each other early enough for a strategy to matter.
If you would like our assistance in organizing and facilitating a structured conversation with your family, please reach out to our team here.
